It’s no secret that in the modern game of baseball, versatility is critical to a team’s success. Managers and front offices like working with flexible lineups that can fit the matchup as best as possible, and utility men are becoming more and more valuable.
To use the 2025 World Series rosters as an example, both the Los Angeles Dodgers and Toronto Blue Jays roster players with defensive versatility. Guys like Addison Barger, Ernie Clement, Kiké Hernandez, and Tommy Edman are all more than capable of playing multiple positions. With platoon becoming a staple of success, this is an important aspect in roster construction.
The 2025 Cincinnati Reds, unfortunately, did not find much success from their utility man, Santiago Espinal. For most of the season, he was a black hole on offense. With him not being anything special defensively anywhere on the field, it became harder and harder to justify any playing time as the season went on.
Let’s dig into some of his numbers from 2025 and why the Reds have to move on from him.
Reds Should Move On from Utility Man Santiago Espinal
Espinal’s Contract
First things first, demoting Espinal to Triple-A is not an option for the Reds, as he has zero options remaining. He is entering his final year of arbitration and will be a free agent following the 2026 season.
At 30 years old, and the production he’s provided, it would be difficult to see him receive a contract larger than the $2.5 million mark he signed for last season during arbitration.
Espinal’s Defensive Roles
Espinal’s role on the team is purely a bench utility man. In 2025, here’s how many games he played at each position:
1B: 3 (2 starts) / -1 DRS
2B: 19 (14 starts) / -1 DRS
3B: 75 (50 starts) / 0 DRS
SS: 2 (0 starts) / 0 DRS
LF: 10 (4 starts) / 0 DRS
RF: 6 (5 starts) / 0 DRS
Not only was he able to handle these positions, he was also about league average at every single one of them in Defensive Runs Saved.
Offensive Production (or Lack Thereof)
Espinal suffered the worst season of his career in 2025 with a .575 OPS, 57 OPS+, and a -1.4 bWAR. All three of these are career lows.
He laced the cleats for 114 games and had 328 plate appearances, which are both basically on par with his career average. While he was never much of a power-hitting threat, he frustratingly had no home runs all season after popping nine over the fence in 2024.
It was the first full season in Espinal’s career where he had no home runs (0 HRs in 26 G – 2020). Subsequently, he posted his lowest slugging percentage of his career at .282.
It’s easy to harp on a bench piece for struggling at the plate, but Espinal’s performance was simply hurting the team. Speed, another important aspect on every MLB bench, was a non-factor in Espinal’s game as well. He stole just two bases while getting caught once, essentially a non-threat on the base-paths.
This was following a 2024 season that saw him steal 11 bases, getting caught just twice. The problem wasn’t his sprint speed, as it was 27.3 feet per second in 2024 and 27.1 feet per second in 2025. Technically, he was slower in 2025, but it is by such a small amount that it is a negligible difference.
Did the Reds keep Sal Stewart in the minors just so they didn’t have to lose Santiago Espinal? pic.twitter.com/tgXCpcbJQB
— Chatterbox Sports (@CBoxSports) September 1, 2025
Where Espinal’s Value Comes From
Through the storm of negatives, Espinal does have one clear-cut strength: plate discipline. In 2025, he had a 23.9 Chase%, 14.1 Whiff%, and 11.6 K%, all among the top of the league. However, these metrics did not result in a high walk rate (6.4 BB%) as pitchers will simply attack the zone since he is not an offensive threat.
These metrics also come with the caveat that Espinal does not make quality contact whatsoever when he does hit the ball. His 25.7 Hard-Hit% and 86.5 Average Exit Velocity are both at the bottom of the league.
Espinal does not chase and does not strike out, but he does not turn that into anything positive other than weak putouts in play. As a bench piece, though, this can still come in handy during late-game situations when there is a “move him over/get him in” situation, where there is a runner in scoring position that a ground ball or fly ball can allow them to advance/score.
Decision Time for the Reds
It might be quite difficult to shop Espinal on the trade market as they would likely get nothing noteworthy in return, but the Reds should still look to cut ties one way or another.
The infield is filled to the brim, and there are many young, highly touted infield prospects brewing in the minor leagues.
As discussed, Espinal is productive in one very specific situation.
These situations, however, are so rare in the grand scheme of a 162-game season that it begs the question of whether a team would be willing to make around $2 million for this one micro area of the game, when they can easily find better all-around bench pieces at the same price, if not even cheaper.
Main Photo Credit: Katie Stratman-Imagn Images
The post Reds Could Look Into Upgrade at Utility Man Position appeared first on Last Word On Baseball.